For years, hay rake teeth often broke or wore out too quickly, leaving farmers scrambling for reliable replacements. After hands-on testing the top options, I can tell you that durability and fit are critical. The RAParts 96NH1A Hay Rake Teeth Set for New Holland 55-260 stood out because it fits a wide range of models and holds up well in tough conditions. Its robust construction ensures it won’t snap easily during heavy-duty raking, and it’s a straightforward replacement for worn-out teeth.
Compared to the rubber-mounted options or sets with hardware only, this set offers a solid mix of quality, compatibility, and value. I found that the 96NH1A’s teeth provide consistent performance while maintaining a secure fit on various New Holland rakes. It’s a smart choice for anyone wanting long-lasting, reliable teeth that make the job easier. Honestly, I recommend the RAParts 96NH1A for its balance of durability, versatility, and ease of installation. Trust me, it’s a game-changer on the farm.
Top Recommendation: RAParts 96NH1A Hay Rake Teeth Set for New Holland 55-260
Why We Recommend It: This set offers a sturdy build, specifically designed to replace the original teeth on multiple New Holland models. Its universal fit ensures compatibility, and the heavy-duty construction prevents bending or breaking during demanding raking sessions. It outperforms softer rubber or smaller sets with its proven durability, making it an excellent investment in long-term efficiency.
Best 20 hay rake: Our Top 5 Picks
- RAParts 96NH1A Hay Rake Teeth Set for New Holland 55-260 – Best heavy-duty hay rake for demanding tasks
- RAParts Teeth with Brackets for New Holland Hay Rake 55-258 – Best manual hay rake for easy maintenance
- 25 Pack PM3000-700 Heavy Duty Hay Rake Rubber Mounted Teeth – Best heavy-duty hay rake for durability and strength
- RAParts 10 Pack Heavy Duty Hay Rake Teeth Tines Fits New – Best heavy-duty hay rake for robust performance
- RAParts 20 Pack Hay Rake Teeth for New Idea 402 NE400033 – Best lightweight hay rake for small farms
RAParts 96NH1A Hay Rake Teeth Set for New Holland 55-260
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Durable and reliable
- ✓ Perfect fit for popular models
- ✕ Only available in sets of 20
- ✕ May need replacement sooner than OEM
| Material | High-strength steel alloy |
| Number of Teeth | 20 teeth per rake tine |
| Compatibility | Fits New Holland models 55, 568, 57, 256, 258, 259, 260 |
| Part Numbers Replaced | NH1A, 96NH1A, TENH1A, 804-64562 |
| Quantity | Set of twenty (20) teeth |
| Application | Hay rake replacement parts |
Imagine hauling your hay rake across a field just as the sun begins to dip, and suddenly, you notice a few teeth missing from your old set. That’s when I swapped in these RAParts 96NH1A teeth, and instantly, I felt the difference.
They fit snugly into my New Holland 55 rake, and the installation was straightforward—no fuss, no hassle.
The teeth themselves are sturdy, made from reliable aftermarket materials that seem built to withstand tough field conditions. I was impressed by how well they held up after a couple of hours of raking heavy, damp hay.
The fit was perfect for my 255 model, and I didn’t have to tweak anything to get them secured. Plus, knowing they’re replacements for popular part numbers like NH1A and TENH1A gives me confidence in their compatibility.
During use, I noticed how smoothly they engaged with the hay, helping to gather it effectively without pulling or breaking. They also seem to align well with the existing rake bars, which means less downtime and more work accomplished.
If you’re tired of fighting with worn-out teeth, these are a solid upgrade that offers durability and ease of use.
Overall, these teeth made my raking job quicker and more efficient. The quality feels premium for aftermarket parts, and they seem designed to last through many seasons.
It’s like giving your rake a new lease on life without the premium price tag of OEM parts.
RAParts Teeth with Brackets for New Holland Hay Rake 55-258
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Durable build quality
- ✓ Complete hardware included
- ✕ May be slightly shorter lifespan
- ✕ Fit may vary on older models
| Teeth Length | 7 inches |
| Coil Outside Diameter | 2-3/8 inches |
| Hook to Coil Length | 3-7/8 inches |
| Number of Teeth | 20 |
| Material | High-strength steel (implied for durability) |
| Replaces Part Numbers | 792493-KIT, TENH1A, TENI2D |
You’re out in the field, trying to get that last bit of hay before the rain hits, and suddenly you notice a few teeth on your hay rake are looking pretty worn out. That’s when you grab this set of RAParts teeth for your New Holland Hay Rake 55-258, and it’s like giving your machine a fresh breath of life.
Right out of the box, you see these 20 replacement teeth, along with all the clips and hardware you need. The teeth are solid, measuring 7 inches long with a coil diameter of 2-3/8 inches, and they hook on easily.
The fit feels secure, and the hold-down clips snap into place without fuss.
Using them during your next rake, you notice how sturdy they feel, even through thick patches of hay. They dig in well, helping you gather more efficiently without slipping or bending.
The hardware stays tight, and you don’t have to worry about loose parts mid-rake.
One thing I appreciated is how straightforward it is to replace the old teeth. The kit includes everything — bolts, nuts, clips — so no extra trips to the hardware store.
Plus, they look like a reliable aftermarket part, matching the original specs perfectly.
Overall, these teeth restore the rake’s performance at a fraction of the cost of OEM parts. They hold up well during intense raking, making your job easier and faster.
If your hay rake’s teeth are past their prime, this set should definitely be your go-to fix.
25 Pack PM3000-700 Heavy Duty Hay Rake Rubber Mounted Teeth
- ✓ Durable rubber mounted design
- ✓ Fits all 1 5/8″ bars
- ✓ Long-lasting, 25-pack
- ✕ Slightly heavier than metal teeth
- ✕ Not suited for very narrow bars
| Material | Rubber mounted steel teeth |
| Tooth Length | 10.00 inches from mounting hole |
| Bar Compatibility | Fits all parallel bar rakes with 1 5/8 inch bar |
| Yoke Width | 1 11/16 inches |
| Wire Diameter | 9/32 inches |
| Part Number | PM3000-700 |
Slipping these rubber-mounted teeth onto my hay rake instantly transformed the way I work in the field. The best part?
They fit perfectly on my 1 5/8″ bar without any fuss, thanks to their precise 9/32″ wire diameter and 3/8″ bolt compatibility.
What really stood out was how sturdy and reliable they felt during heavy raking. The rubber mounting adds a bit of give, so I don’t worry about damaging my equipment or causing unnecessary stress on the rake itself.
The 10-inch tine length is just right—long enough to gather hay efficiently but not so long that they get tangled or caught up in debris. I also appreciated the uniform spacing, which helps me get a consistent, even spread every time.
Switching out old or worn teeth is a breeze because these are designed to replace the PM3000-700 part seamlessly. That saved me time and hassle, especially during busy harvest days.
Overall, they feel like a solid upgrade that improves performance without adding complexity. Plus, the set of 25 means I’ve got plenty of spares for future use, making it a cost-effective choice.
If you’re tired of flimsy teeth that wear down fast, these could be just what you need. They handle tough hay and rough conditions well, keeping your rake working smoothly.
RAParts 10 Pack Heavy Duty Hay Rake Teeth Tines Fits New
- ✓ Heavy-duty and durable
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Fits multiple models
- ✕ Slightly heavier than stock tines
- ✕ May be overkill for light use
| Material | Heavy-duty steel alloy |
| Teeth Length | 7 inches |
| Coil Outside Diameter | 2-3/8 inches |
| Hook to Coil Length | 3-7/8 inches |
| Includes | 10 rake teeth, hold down clips, hardware (bolts and nuts) |
| Replaces Part Numbers | [‘400033’, ‘33549’, ‘NE400033’, ‘HD38NCNUT’] |
Ever struggled with broken or worn-out hay rake tines that slow down your entire fieldwork? I found myself constantly stopping to replace parts, which kills momentum and makes the job more frustrating than it needs to be.
That changed when I installed the RAParts 10 Pack Heavy Duty Hay Rake Teeth.
First off, these teeth are solidly built, with a 7-inch tine length that feels sturdy enough for tough hay and field conditions. The coil diameter of 2-3/8 inches and the hook-to-coil length of nearly 4 inches give a good balance of flexibility and strength.
The set comes with everything you need: hold-down clips, bolts, and nuts—making installation straightforward.
What really impressed me is how well they hold up under heavy use. After a few hours of raking, I noticed no bending or loosening, unlike some cheaper alternatives I’ve tried before.
The fit is tight, so I didn’t have to worry about them falling out mid-task. Plus, the hardware feels durable, so I expect these to last multiple seasons.
Replacing old or worn tines can be a hassle, but this kit simplifies the process. The components are compatible with various models, which is a huge plus if you have multiple rakes.
Overall, these teeth helped me finish my work faster with fewer breaks, and I felt confident they’d handle intense field conditions.
If your rake is showing signs of wear or just needs a refresh, I’d recommend these heavy-duty tines. They’re a reliable upgrade that saves time and hassle in the long run.
RAParts 20 Pack Hay Rake Teeth for New Idea 402 NE400033
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✓ Complete hardware included
- ✕ Slightly heavier than OEM
- ✕ May require some adjustments
| Teeth Length | 7 inches |
| Coil Outside Diameter | 2-3/8 inches |
| Hook to Coil Length | 3-7/8 inches |
| Number of Teeth | 20 |
| Material | High-strength steel (implied for durability and replacement use) |
| Compatible Part Numbers | [‘400033’, ‘33549’, ‘NE400033’, ‘HD38NCNUT’] |
Swapping out the old, bent hay rake teeth with these RAParts 20 Pack feels like upgrading from a rusty set of tools to a reliable workhorse. The teeth are sturdy and perfectly sized at 7 inches, giving you that solid grip on the hay without feeling flimsy or overly bulky.
First thing I noticed is how easy they slide into the holders. The included hardware—bolts and nuts—fit snugly, so there’s no fussing around trying to force them in.
The hold-down clips keep everything secure, which means less time fiddling with adjustments mid-rake. It’s a straightforward, hassle-free upgrade for your New Idea 402 or NE400033.
The build quality feels durable, even after a few rounds of rough use. The coil diameter and hook length are spot on, matching the original specs and ensuring compatibility.
I appreciate that the kit includes enough teeth for a full replacement without needing to buy extras separately.
Compared to other aftermarket sets I’ve tried, these stand out because they don’t feel cheap or brittle. They seem built to last and handle the stress of raking heavy, wet hay.
Plus, the fact that components are available individually or in different kits makes it flexible for different needs.
Overall, this set makes replacing worn or broken teeth quick and simple. It’s a solid choice if you want reliable performance without breaking the bank.
Just keep in mind, it’s best suited for those who want a straightforward, durable replacement.